When to Resurface vs. Replace a Concrete Driveway

Your driveway is more than just a place to park—it’s one of the first things people notice about your home. Over time, however, Newfoundland’s harsh weather can take its toll on concrete surfaces. If your driveway is cracked, stained, or looking worse for wear, the big question becomes: Should you resurface it, or is it time to replace it entirely?
At Concrete Contractor St. Johns, we help homeowners make the right decision based on condition, budget, and long-term value. Here’s how to tell which option is best for your driveway.
🔍 What Is Concrete Resurfacing?
Concrete resurfacing involves applying a thin overlay to the top of your existing driveway. This overlay bonds with the surface, covering minor cracks, stains, and imperfections while giving the driveway a fresh new look.
Best for:
- Surface-level cracks
- Discoloration or fading
- Minor pitting or scaling
- Homeowners on a budget
💣 What Is Concrete Replacement?
Replacement is the complete removal and reinstallation of your concrete driveway. It’s more invasive and expensive, but necessary when the structural integrity of the slab is compromised.
Best for:
- Large or deep cracks
- Major sinking or heaving
- Severe surface erosion
- Driveways older than 25–30 years
🧱 Resurface If...
✅ The concrete is
mostly intact, with only cosmetic damage
✅ Cracks are
less than 1/4-inch wide and not deep
✅ The slab is still
level and drains properly
✅ You’re looking for a
cost-effective refresh
✅ You want to
change the look with a stamped or decorative finish
Bonus: Resurfacing can give your driveway a brand-new look without the cost of tearing it out.
🚫 Replace If...
❌ Cracks are
wide, deep, or growing
❌ There’s significant
settling, heaving, or uneven sections
❌ The base beneath the slab is
unstable or compromised
❌ Previous resurfacing jobs have
already failed
❌ You want to make
structural changes, such as widening the driveway
In these cases, resurfacing is only a temporary fix—and the underlying issues will return.
💬 Local Tip from St. John’s Pros
Due to Newfoundland’s freeze-thaw cycles, even minor cracks can grow quickly if not addressed properly. If you're unsure about your driveway’s condition, it's best to get a professional inspection.
🔨 Let’s Make the Right Call Together
At Concrete Contractor St. Johns, we specialize in both resurfacing and full driveway replacement. We’ll assess your concrete, explain your options clearly, and recommend the solution that makes the most sense for your home and budget.
📍 Serving St. John’s, Mount Pearl, Paradise, and surrounding areas.
Need a quote or on-site assessment?
Reach out to
Concrete Contractor St. Johns today—we’ll help restore the strength, safety, and beauty of your driveway.









